uberhoot
Thursday, July 12, 2007
  Wrong caption
I'm sittin there in the cafeteria today eating some godforsaken corporate salad, and I come across today's installment of that old creaky standby, Mother Goose & Grimm, a comic apparently about an old goose and her dog, except when it is in random service of a play on words, and features neither Mother Goose nor Grimm.

So I read this caption and immediately sensed that something was off. Would this not have been funnier (well, relative to the world of MG&G) had the caption been "Careful, these plates are *hot*?" What's with the cold? That's just crappy punchline writing, is what that is. I mean, I see that he is going for this broad sort of "things are different in Hell" approach, the old "Ha ha this is the opposite of what it actually should be" trope upon which comic dinosaurs perpetually lean, but had the plates been hot, this would have actually elevated the punchline from "opposite" to "irony," which should be a concept covered in Syndicated Comic Dinosaurs 101.

Someone fire this guy. Oh wait-- Once you are syndicated in the paper, you apparently have tenure beyond even the grave, so never mind*.

*Although allow me to add that in using the example of Charles Schultz, I mean no disrespect, since although his later life comics seemed to revolve around school children spending a lot of time on the golf course, he is one of the great comic writers of all time, and probably deserves his post-lifetime pass.
 
Comments:
"Careful, these plates are hot." would be the caption if it appeared in the New Yorker.
 
What happened to the Bento?!
 
Sadly I haven't exactly been a model of cooking and pre-planning these days... hence, I am only known as a half-assed environmentalist.
 
You are so right about that caption!

I really do not understand why newspapers keep so many elderly/nearly dead/completely dead cartoonists employed. Is our generation completely lacking cartoonists to take over so these poor saps can retire already? Are newspapers and cartoonists in a race to the grave?

All I can say is Tiny Dog, you have your finger on the pulse according to this article from yesterday's
SF Chronicle:
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007/07/10/national/a141503D81.DTL&hw=study+about+humor&sn=001&sc=1000
 
Arrrrg. It doesn't look like that url is readable, so I'm trying again:

old people can't get jokes article
 
Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]





<< Home

Art blog.

This is now a blog for art projects. That means scans, junk you did, photographs, projects. No text rambles. Death to text rambles! That is all.

Archives
June 2007 / July 2007 / August 2007 / September 2007 / October 2007 / November 2007 / December 2007 / January 2008 / February 2008 /


Powered by Blogger

Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]